Step 1 — Identify the failure mode. Not the product. The failure mode. Oxygen ingress, moisture loss, moisture gain, aroma loss, or mechanical puncture. These need different structures, and most wasted samples come from specifying the wrong one first.

Step 2 — Write the shelf life as a number. "Long shelf life" is not a specification. Thirty days at 4 °C and 65 % RH is. The humidity figure is what determines the barrier you need.

Step 3 — Fix the format before the material. Vacuum, skin, shrink, thermoform, FFS, lidding. The format constrains the structure, and the structure constrains the gauge. Doing this in the reverse order wastes a trial.

Step 4 — Check the recyclability constraint. If your customer has a mono-material commitment, PE/EVOH/PE is your starting point, not an afterthought. Building it in later means re-qualifying.

Step 5 — Only now talk to a supplier. With the failure mode, the shelf life, the format and the recyclability constraint written down, any supplier conversation becomes a comparison of structures rather than a sales pitch. If a supplier cannot answer within that frame, that is itself useful information.

The question that eliminates half the options: if your product is fatty, does the seal layer need to be oil-resistant? This single requirement rules out more standard grades than any other factor, and it is the one most often missed at specification stage.